Top-secret negotiations on a budget in which the figures are rewritten at the last minute. Without economic logic or wider context, just to make the numbers add up. A thing of the past, buried in dust thanks to the reform of public finances and expert capacity at the Ministry of Finance? Not at all! The coalition is putting on just such a show for us, live.
The Budgetary Rules Act, which
governs the management of the entire state, sets 15 October as the deadline
for submitting the government's draft budget to parliament. On that very day
– for the first time this year – the cabinet will discuss the most important law of the year.
In fact it will merely approve it; there is no time left for discussion. Then again, there would
be nothing to discuss anyway, since the draft was not published before the government meeting. Citizens,
experts and even ministers are being kept until the last minute
in uncertainty about what next year's budget will actually bring.
Thanks to Monday's slip by the Ministry
of Finance, which published an incomplete draft on its website for
approximately 5 minutes, the quicker among us had the chance to get at least the rough outlines
of what the coalition leaders have been preparing for us behind the scenes for next year. And it must
be admitted that the draft was simply teeming with surprises. The very first is the fact that
the Ministry of Finance did not bother to prepare the budget in both Slovak crowns and euros,
as it requires of all private entities, and prepared for the government meeting
only its euro version. Another is the increase in expenditure of the budget chapters by an incredible
SKK 17.5 billion (author's calculation). Where will the government get the money for this, if it
is truly sincere about reducing the general government deficit? In searching for an answer
to this question, the reader comes across perhaps the biggest surprise.
The casualness with which the Ministry
of Finance is stretching the revenue side suggests that the deficit will not, after all, be the most important
parameter of this budget. The government will not find it hard to find an excuse for missing it,
since the financial crisis is raging on our doorstep and even large and influential
countries of the Union have already begun preparing their voters for a loosening of budgetary
discipline. The fact that, to cover expenditure, politicians simply painted into
the budget revenue from the sale of state property (SKK 2.5 billion), dividends from
state-owned enterprises (SKK 1.5 billion) and the reopening of the second pillar (SKK 7
billion) cannot be described as anything other than manipulating the figures to make the numbers
add up.
A budget drawn up in this way carries two serious
risks, which was not customary in the past after the reform of public finances. The first is
the estimate of economic growth and the tax revenue linked to it. The Ministry of Finance
has barely changed its macroeconomic forecasts from the summer, and if the Slovak
economy slows more than the budget expects, this will inevitably be reflected in lower
tax collection. The second, even more significant risk is the assumption that 150
thousand people will leave the second pillar. Whereas last year the government "helped" savers
decide to leave by extending the minimum period of saving for a pension from
10 to 15 years, no similar measure is planned for next year.
Relying on the public's fear of the financial crisis to supply ministries with extra cash
is not only short-sighted on the government's part, but also irresponsible.
Ján Marušinec