In the global ranking of budget
transparency, Slovakia – thanks in part to the changes made in this area over
the past two years – placed 15th out of the 100 participating countries.
With a score of 67 points (out of a maximum of 100), in a regional
comparison of the countries of Central and Eastern Europe it moved, together with the Czech Republic,
into the leading positions and thus, in terms of the transparency of the
budget process, came closer to Germany. Despite this positive result,
many significant shortcomings persist, particularly in reporting, audit and public
participation in the budget process.
The analyses carried out in Slovakia for the second time (the first assessment took place in 2010) within the OBI (Open Budget Initiative) project by the Center for Economic and Social Analyses MESA 10 show that several positive changes have been made in budgetary policy, concerning above all changes in the structure of the budget itself; the positive trend was also helped by the introduction of fiscal rules on public debt and of the fiscal council, which, especially in the future, if its competences are gradually strengthened, can contribute more significantly to stronger oversight of the management of public resources. Thanks in part to these changes, Slovakia moved up as many as 13 places in the budget transparency ranking, overtaking, for example, Poland as well as Croatia, Bulgaria and Ukraine. In the regional comparison, only Germany, the Czech Republic, Slovenia and Russia now have a more open budget process.
The shortcomings that persist concern above all the publication of more detailed information on the impacts of planned changes in government policy on public expenditure and on in-year budget execution, as well as on the structure of public debt and the financial and non-financial assets of the state. In future, the budget should not rely on just one macroeconomic forecast, but should be broadened in this respect and take into account several scenarios of economic development, including the possible impacts of these different scenarios on public finances. In future, the government, i.e. the executive, should consult the legislature, i.e. the National Council of the Slovak Republic, more both on transfers of funds and on the actual setting of budget priorities for the coming year, even before the government's draft budget is submitted to parliament. The budget's starting points should be based on clearly identified government priorities and intentions for the coming period, which should then also be reflected in the priorities of the budget itself. Last but not least, the persisting shortcomings in audit should be mentioned. In the coming years, there should be a thorough audit not only of selected but of all budget expenditure and, where shortcomings or errors in the management of public resources are found, there should be not only remedial action but also the publication of a report on what steps, if any, the government took after learning of the audit results.
Budget transparency alone is not enough to improve the management of public finances and public affairs in general. Only transparency in combination with personal engagement and public participation in the whole process will make it possible to maximise the positive effects of greater openness of the budget process to public scrutiny. Unfortunately, in Slovakia there are as yet no formal requirements for public participation in the budget process, and there is also no mechanism for involving the public in the planning, approval and execution of the budget. The public does have the opportunity to submit complaints if it identifies shortcomings in the management of public resources, but above all there is practically no subsequent feedback from the government and the supreme audit institutions to let the public know how a given complaint was dealt with. The government, the legislature and the supreme audit institutions all have the opportunity to remove all these shortcomings and involve the public in the entire budget process. These measures do not require significant additional resources to implement; all it takes is the will and courage to make the necessary changes and improve the current state of affairs.
The OBI assessment is based on a detailed analysis of each individual phase of the budget process. OBI 2012 (Open Budget Initiative/Open Budget Index), or OBS 2012 (Open Budget Survey), is the only internationally recognised ranking of countries in terms of budget transparency, updated every two years. The comparison of countries, the detailed analysis of the entire budget process and the final compilation of the ranking are based on the methodology of the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank and the OECD. The results of the analyses are verified by two independent experts, and the Ministry of Finance itself was also given the opportunity to comment. In our country, the survey took place from June 2011 to December 2012, and the subject of the assessment was mainly the state budget and the general government budget for 2011-2013. The assessment is repeated regularly every two years; the next one will take place in 2015.
MESA 10 documents
Press release: Slovakia has made significant progress in the transparency of the budget process (23.1.2013)
Open Budget Index 2012: Slovakia – overview of results
Open Budget Survey 2012: Slovakia country summary (in English)
Charts and ranking
International Budget Partnership documents
Open Budget Survey 2012: international press release
Open Budget Survey 2012 – full report and key findings
Open Budget Survey 2012: methodology (internationalbudget.org)
Questionnaire for Slovakia (Open Budget Survey 2012) (internationalbudget.org)
Blank Open Budget Survey 2012 questionnaire (internationalbudget.org)
Infographic with the results of the Open Budget Survey 2012 (internationalbudget.org)
Data
Database of detailed results for all countries 2006 – 2012 (XLSX)
Open Budget Survey Data Explorer · Open Budget Survey on the IBP website
About the Open Budget Initiative project
The aim of the project is to produce comprehensible analyses and surveys assessing whether the government of a given country gives the public access to budget information and whether it gives citizens the opportunity to participate in the budget process. The Open Budget Initiative is a project of the International Budget Partnership (IBP), which works with partner organisations from 100 countries around the world.



