News › 2008
Article and commentary · 5 February 2008 · Slovakia

USA: Elections 2008 (2)

SuperMac from Super Tuesday?
The presidential election merry-go-round continues today with so-called Super Tuesday in 24 states: primary elections are being held in sixteen states, caucuses in eight, and in West Virginia there will be a Republican convention. Both parties are voting simultaneously in nineteen states. The scale of today is best illustrated by a brief excursion into history – in 2004 Super Tuesday consisted of elections in 10 states.

What has happened in the month since the primaries began?
In the Republican camp, John McCain has surged to the front of the electoral peloton. Two other candidates remain in the race: Mitt Romney and Mike Huckabee. Each has won something – in Iowa Huckabee outwitted Romney, and then McCain beat Romney in New Hampshire. Romney, however, came back from the dead and won the primaries in Michigan and Nevada, leaving McCain only second and third place respectively. South Carolina and Florida, which McCain won, nevertheless showed that the three decorated winners of the six primaries form a clear ranking: 1. McCain (3), 2. Romney (2), 3. Huckabee (1). Moreover, the lead of McCain, whose campaign many had written off at the end of last year, is even greater in national opinion polls, where he leads Romney by 2:1.  

We have seen other things too: the candle of hope of former New York mayor Rudolph Giuliani was blown out by the breeze of the Florida primary shortly after it was lit. Giuliani was let down by his own “mathematical” model of participation in the primaries (see “It’s a long way from Iowa to Washington”, 5 January 2008). He withdrew from the campaign after finishing only third in Florida with less than 15%, not even half of McCain’s share. Another candidate, Fred Thompson, failed to make much of an impression, stayed at the tail of the candidate field and withdrew from the campaign after the South Carolina primary. That was the best result of his campaign – but third place with 15.7% was too little to keep him in the game. He needed to win. The last of the Republican candidates, Ron Paul, has shone only with second place in Nevada, where he won his highest share of the vote so far – 13.7%; but that is all he has achieved to date.  

In the Democratic camp the contest narrowed fairly quickly to the expected favourites – Senator Hillary Clinton and Senator Barack Obama. John Edwards withdrew after the Florida primary, which sealed his sad debacle in South Carolina – the state where he was born and the only one where he won the primary in 2004. He told voters: “We hear you once again. And we will lift you up with our dream of what’s possible.”

Hillary Clinton did not start well. In Iowa she was overtaken not only by Senator Obama but also by Senator Edwards. She came back victorious in New Hampshire, however, came first in Nevada and convincingly left Obama behind in the Florida primary. Obama, for his part, began with a surprise victory in Iowa and won decisively in South Carolina. What matters, however, is that he has also caught up with Senator Clinton in national polls and in states where until recently Hillary had been expected to win (New Jersey, Arizona, Missouri, California).  

Super Tuesday
While in the Republican camp it seems clear who has the most support and who is second in line, among the Democrats the situation is different. Since no one is first, no one is clearly second either. And this is not expected to change after today, since according to estimates the two candidates should split the votes. The duel between the two rivals may thus continue long after Super Tuesday, and it cannot be ruled out that it will drag on until the nominating convention in Denver in August. This can be partly attributed to the proportional system of allocating votes that has been used in the Democratic primaries since the 1970s. Although – and this must be added in the same breath – it has never yet led the party into a dead end. A prolonged duel, however, may exhaust the Democrats – they will have to concentrate on an opponent from their own party and in the final contest they may lack both strength and money.

The Super Tuesday Republican contest will be much more interesting, because it may decide the presidential nomination. McCain can expect strong support in the north-eastern states. Mike Huckabee can also be expected to finish with a decent result in the southern states. Huckabee, however, lacks the money for a stronger national campaign and will therefore not threaten McCain. On the contrary, his staying in the race draws away part of Romney’s conservative voters. Mitt Romney, meanwhile, comes out of the debates as a smooth operator who always has the right answer to hand. But, as The Wall Street Journal wrote, many realise that today’s perfectionist Romney was not necessarily a perfect governor. As it turns out, voters are not looking for the top of the class; people are more interested in character than in the right answer. In this duel Romney has so far found no effective weapon against McCain – his emphasis on not being tied to Washington, as McCain is, has not found much resonance. Vin Weber, a former Republican congressman and now political director of Romney’s campaign, recently wrote that: “On each of the major challenges confronting our country, Washington has failed to act. Mr. Romney will not.” Well, he himself has to show how he will handle the nominating contest.

McCain is also well on his way in California. The endorsement of the successful governor A. Schwarzenegger is a strong signal to voters in California, Giuliani’s endorsement in turn in New York and New Jersey, and the endorsement of independent Democratic senator Joseph Lieberman to voters not only in Connecticut. For McCain, however, the most important thing will be whether he manages to win the support of the conservative wing of the Republican Party. That is also why in recent days he has emphasised that it should be known that he “will reject any Democratic proposal to raise taxes and will support Supreme Court nominees like Alito and Roberts.” McCain will need the conservative wing of the party to unite the party, but also as practical support in the contest for the nomination and the presidency – it is precisely this wing that helps most through its volunteers in the presidential campaign. With exactly this aim, McCain’s 96-year-old mother recently came out in support of her son, telling journalists that Republican voters should just “hold their noses” and vote for her son.

SuperMac
If anyone is the favourite of Super Tuesday, then, it is John McCain. And it probably holds true that Mac, as McCain is nicknamed, can win everything today and Romney can lose everything. If that happens, Super Tuesday will give birth to SuperMac. The electoral contest, however, will go on. The more clearly the contours of the nominations in both camps take shape, the more interesting the debate on the candidates’ ideas on all issues will become. Whoever wins it will take the presidential oath in January.

© Milan Ježovica

Translated from Slovak · 5 February 2008