The Rewards Of a Larger NATO
Greg Craig and Ronald D. Asmus
Monday, 19 February 2007; page A19
In the context of Russian President Vladimir Putin’s speech at the security conference in Munich, the authors assess the benefits of NATO enlargement – for the organisation itself and for Europe as a whole, including Russia. So what is their current assessment?
Russian President Vladimir Putin’s aggressive speech at the security conference in Munich on 10 February has led some people to revive their arguments against NATO enlargement.
The critics were wrong when they opposed enlarging the alliance’s membership in the 1990s, and they are still wrong. In fact, the more time has passed, the better the arguments in favour of enlargement look. In essence there were three main reasons for NATO’s expansion, and each of them has proved correct.
First, NATO enlargement was meant to provide a security shield behind which the countries of Central and Eastern Europe could bury their historical conflicts and integrate peacefully with the West. The result is that Europe is more democratic, more peaceful and more secure than before. All of us – Europeans, Americans and Russians – benefit from this.
Second, we enlarged NATO as a hedge against a Russia that might once again develop into a regional bully and threat. Imagine what Central Europe would look like today had we not enlarged the alliance: the leaders of Central and Eastern Europe would be spending more time worrying about how to resist Russian pressure than building democratic institutions and managing strong, market-oriented economies.
The third reason for enlarging NATO was broader and strategic. If Europe were not more secure today, it would be much harder to persuade our (European) allies to engage with us in places such as Afghanistan or the Middle East.
To say that the West has gained nothing from NATO enlargement is to miss the forest for the trees. Although many of the new NATO members are still poorer than the countries of Western Europe, their per capita contribution to the alliance is higher than that of most Western European allies. The nations of Central and Eastern Europe are democratic, stable and prosperous. They have the self-confidence and the means to cope with the rise of a nationalist Russia.
In fact, with NATO enlargement we have gained far more than the Czech navy. We have gained a Europe whole and free. And we have an alliance that is better prepared to protect us from the threats of the future precisely because it has laid to rest many ghosts of the past. And that is a very good deal.
To read the article, click on:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/02/18/AR2007021800902.html
News › 2007
Article and commentary · 19 February 2007 · Slovakia