Position of the To dá rozum initiative on the government bill amending and supplementing Act No. 131/2002 Coll. on Higher Education Institutions and on amendments to certain acts, as amended, and amending certain acts, and on the government bill on quality assurance in higher education
On the proposal of the Government of the Slovak Republic, two legal norms will be the subject of the second and third readings in the National Council of the Slovak Republic; their approval in the submitted form threatens to reduce the transparency and expertise of the quality assessment of higher education institutions. At the same time, the objectivity of the financing of research and development activities of higher education institutions in Slovakia is at risk. The To dá rozum initiative has identified serious shortcomings in these legal norms, concerning mainly two areas: the independence and expertise of the assessment of education and of the research, development and artistic activities of higher education institutions.
The first fundamental objection is that, despite the Ministry of Education's declared efforts to increase the independence of the quality assessment of higher education institutions, the submitted legal norms envisage exactly the opposite – a substantial increase in the ministry's influence on the quality assessment of higher education institutions. Unlike the current situation, the ministry is taking upon itself the definition of the criteria (standards) for assessing the internal quality systems of higher education institutions (the basis of institutional accreditation), study programmes, and the conduct of habilitation proceedings (for awarding the title of associate professor) and proceedings for the appointment of professors, as well as for assessing the research, development and artistic activities of higher education institutions.
The ministry, however, does not have sufficient expert capacity to cover the individual fields of research and study programmes and to be able to define accreditation criteria (standards) for them, or criteria for assessing research and development activities for funding purposes. At present these criteria are proposed by the Accreditation Commission, which is composed of experts in the individual fields of research. They have worked in their field over the long term and have an overview of important trends, publication practices and artistic achievements specific to the field. The act, however, envisages abolishing the Accreditation Commission and replacing it with an Accreditation Agency and a commission for the assessment of research, development and artistic activities, with unclear criteria for selecting their members.
This is an important issue, because the criteria for assessing study programmes, habilitation and inaugural proceedings and internal quality systems will determine the ability to offer study programmes, appoint associate professors and nominate professors. In other words, it is a question of the very existence of a higher education institution and its activities.
The proposed method of assessing research, development and artistic activities will also have an existential impact on the activities of a higher education institution, since it will be one of the aspects assessed by the new Accreditation Agency when granting accreditation for habilitation and inaugural proceedings. At the same time, it will be one of the criteria for allocating institutional funding for research and development at public higher education institutions. Institutional funding for research and development is allocated as part of subsidies from the state budget and makes up the vast majority of public higher education institutions' resources for these activities.
The second serious shortcoming, this time in the bill on quality assurance in higher education, is above all the method of nominating members of the Executive Board of the new Accreditation Agency. The act does not set out a mechanism to ensure, as is currently the case with the Accreditation Commission, that every, or at least most, scientific and artistic fields will be represented on it. The risk that the diverse scientific/artistic fields will not be adequately represented raises questions as to how the Executive Board of the Accreditation Agency will be able to compile a list of assessors (identifying leading experts in specific fields) and from them form working groups to carry out quality assessments in various areas of education and of the scientific and artistic activities of higher education institutions. It is highly questionable how, under these conditions, members of the Executive Board will be able to assess proposals to grant or refuse accreditation in a field in which none of them is versed.
The identified shortcomings, which threaten a substantial reduction in the transparency of the process of assessing the quality of education and of scientific and artistic activities, as well as a reduction in the quality of the process itself, cannot be remedied by amendments. In view of the negative impact that the submitted legal norms may have on these areas, we call for their withdrawal and redrafting.
________________________________________
TO DÁ ROZUM: is an initiative preparing a comprehensive change in education based on an analysis of problems in practice and on examples of good practice from Slovakia and abroad.
The project is supported by the European Social Fund through the Effective Public Administration programme.