We presented the results of a survey among Slovak scientists and university teachers working abroad at a press conference on 1 August 2018.
One of the current problems of Slovak higher education is that many Slovak scientists and university teachers work abroad and only sporadically return to work in Slovakia. These people could bring innovation and links to the international academic environment.
The To dá rozum (Learning Makes Sense) project, which aims to prepare a comprehensive change of education in Slovakia, focused in one of its surveys on the reasons why Slovak scientists and university teachers stay abroad. It examined how they perceive the state scheme that is supposed to encourage their return, what the greatest barriers to returning are for them, and in which areas they would be interested in cooperating with Slovak universities.
In most cases, the university teachers and scientists working abroad who took part in the survey did not leave with the intention of staying abroad. Fewer than 19% of respondents had this in mind when they left. Currently, however, more than 43% of them no longer want to return. The most common reasons why respondents decided to stay abroad were higher-level scientific and artistic work, higher pay, sufficient funding for scientific and artistic work, and the opportunity to work with high-quality scientists and artists. Another reason was the non-transparent allocation of grant funding in Slovakia. This was one of the most important reasons for the youngest generation of respondents, aged 24 to 35.
In terms of generational differences, it is also interesting that the generation over 36 more often went abroad only for their doctorate, and those over 40 are now mainly in the USA, the United Kingdom, Austria and Germany. Respondents under 40 are mainly in the Czech Republic, and those under 35 originally went abroad as early as for their bachelor’s or master’s/engineering studies. As many as 60% of our respondents originally went abroad to study at university, rising to 73% for the youngest generation aged 24 to 30. It appears that university study abroad is increasingly the gateway for our respondents to a future career as a scientist or university teacher abroad.
The state programme to support the return of experts has failed
Since 2015, Slovakia has had a Support Scheme for the Return of Experts from Abroad, which also aims to attract scientists and university teachers.
"This scheme is not very successful. In the three years of its existence, it has attracted only 14 experts to Slovak universities. At the same time, from our respondents’ point of view, it is not a reason to return," said Renáta Hall, director of the To dá rozum project. According to respondents, the scheme is problematic mainly because it does not address systemic problems such as funding for research and artistic grants or sufficient salary support from the scheme, nor the lack of high-quality research teams.
As Stanislav Lukáč, To dá rozum’s higher education analyst, put it: "In the survey, we took a closer look at what the biggest barriers to returning are for our respondents and under what circumstances they would return to Slovakia."
According to our respondents, the barriers to returning to Slovak universities include, besides inadequate pay, poorly managed departments, a lack of high-quality colleagues, and a lack of interest in and appreciation of our respondents’ work.
Another finding is that the full return of experts to Slovakia need not be the only way forward for Slovak universities. Cooperation with Slovak universities is also important: it can improve their quality through links to the international academic space and, in future, perhaps also lead to the return of the scientist/university teacher, who can help create the conditions for their own return through such cooperation. "As many as 79% of our respondents have some contact with Slovak institutions, and those considering returning have contact more often than those who are not," adds Lukáč. The importance of contact is also shown by the fact that as many as 36% of respondents who have no contact with Slovak universities or other research institutions see the fact that they do not know anyone at Slovak universities as a barrier to cooperation. The findings show that the existence and intensity of contact increase interest in cooperation. Another significant barrier is that nobody has approached our scientists and university teachers abroad to cooperate, whether to evaluate grant applications, assess the quality of universities or help shape public policies.
The survey also revealed what form of cooperation our respondents are interested in. Besides occasional lecturing, which can be a first step towards deeper cooperation, they are also interested in more systematic cooperation, such as joint research projects or writing academic articles. Such cooperation can help improve the quality of our universities by linking them with the international scientific community. Encouragingly, the majority of our respondents already collaborate on research and on writing articles. Another piece of good news is that as many as 74 respondents are interested in taking part in evaluating applications for scientific and artistic grants, and 44 in assessing the quality of Slovak universities. "This is a very important finding, since we have long lacked independent expert capacity in both these processes, and involving Slovak experts from abroad in these areas can help the entire higher education system in Slovakia," stresses Hall.
Data collection
The questionnaire from which the data are drawn was developed on the basis of qualitative interviews conducted in June and July 2017 with scientists and university teachers who work or have worked abroad, including holders of grants from the state scheme for the return of experts, and on the basis of the international MORE2 study. Quantitative data were collected through questionnaires in May and June 2018. The questionnaire survey was completed by 197 respondents aged 24 to 66, of whom 64% were men and 36% women. The respondents work in 20 countries, the largest numbers being in the Czech Republic, the USA, the United Kingdom, Germany, Austria, the Netherlands, Switzerland, Finland and Sweden. Fields of science were represented in the sample as follows: technical sciences (24), natural sciences (77), social sciences and humanities (70), medical, health and pharmaceutical sciences (26). Of these, as many as 73% of respondents work at universities, 22% at other research institutions and 5% in practice (governmental and non-governmental organisations, the private sector).
TO DÁ ROZUM: is an initiative preparing a comprehensive change of education based on an analysis of problems in practice and on examples of good practice from Slovakia and abroad.
The project is supported by the European Social Fund through the Effective Public Administration programme.