News › 2008
Article and commentary · 25 February 2008 · Slovakia

Rent regulation – a hot potato

Even 18 years after the change of regime, there is an area in which the state flagrantly violates property rights guaranteed by the Constitution of the Slovak Republic. This is the regulation of rents for flats in restituted buildings. By law, the state forces owners to charge current tenants a symbolic rent, without compensation. In essence, it thus pursues social policy at the expense of the owners of these buildings. In practice, owners do not have sufficient rental income even to provide basic maintenance of their property, let alone the possibility of taking out a loan and investing in the renovation of residential buildings.

A proposed solution came from the ministries of construction and justice, which proposed a gradual deregulation of rents and the construction of replacement flats with state support, managed by local governments. This proposal was opposed not only by the tenants concerned but also by the Ministry of Social Affairs and the Prime Minister. The government swept the prepared document off the table without any discussion of it and without even hinting at alternative solutions. Such conduct prolongs the current lethargy, and a real solution is once again postponed.

We can discuss the technical details of the solution proposed by the ministries of construction and justice, but in principle its direction was right. The question of social housing should primarily be addressed individually at the level of each citizen or family, and only then at the local and regional level. The state should intervene only in exceptional cases, and rather in a targeted way in the form of social assistance, and should create conditions for local governments to be able to cope with the problem of social housing.

In light of the above, it is worth recalling the wording of Article 20(4) of the Constitution of the Slovak Republic: “Expropriation or forced restriction of the right of ownership shall be possible only to the extent necessary and in the public interest, on the basis of law and for adequate compensation.” The ministries have been tossing the hot potato of rent deregulation back and forth between them for quite some time; in the latest attempt the central government tried to pass it on to local government. The Prime Minister and the whole cabinet should realise that postponing decisions has so far not helped to solve any problem. Time passes relentlessly, and with it the risk of lawsuits increases, in which the Slovak Republic has only a small chance of success against the owners of restituted properties.

Ján Marušinec, analyst, M.E.S.A.10

Translated from Slovak · 25 February 2008