News › 2009
Article and commentary · 7 April 2009 · Slovakia

The Finance Minister's April Fool's Joke

It is admirable that, despite the havoc wreaked by the economic and financial crisis, the Minister of Finance has not lost his sense of humour. Submitting the document "Draft Framework of the General Government Budget for 2010 to 2012" to the inter-ministerial comment procedure on 1 April cannot be called anything other than a joke. Even the content of the document itself can amuse the reader – provided, that is, that it really is only an April Fool's joke.

Economic growth of 2.4% in 2009 at a time when recession is already being whispered about publicly; an almost doubling of the deficit for 2010 to just under the 3% of GDP threshold required by the Stability and Growth Pact, immediately followed by the statement that "with the proposed deficits Slovakia is continuing its efforts to consolidate public finances"; or the deterioration in the finances of the FNM "caused mainly by financing the fund's expenditure related to its activities" when the privatisation of the assets it manages has been halted for almost 3 years – that is just a brief list of the pearls from the first draft of next year's budget.

And now seriously, because public finances are no joking matter. Since joining the euro area, Slovakia has practically no instrument with which to face the crisis other than sound budgetary policy. The Ministry of Finance itself states in the document that "Owing to the absence of national monetary policy instruments, fiscal policy, structural policies, labour market flexibility and financial market stability will be of much greater importance.". What the framework reveals to us, however, is the government's helplessness in the face of the crisis and an uncontrolled, haphazard course of events reflected in the rapidly deteriorating state of public finances. The government's unwillingness or inability to adopt systemic measures is leading not only to the country running up debt, but also to a gradual loss of confidence among financial and strategic investors in the health of our economy. That confidence, however, is key to reviving growth once the crisis has blown over.


The government's measures so far, passed off as anti-crisis measures, are mostly missing the mark. The car scrappage scheme, paid for with Slovak taxpayers' money, mainly supports foreign production; bailing out untransformed or unprivatised state companies (Cargo, ŽSR, Lesy SR, hospitals) encourages moral hazard among politically appointed management and creates hidden debts. The government will not budge on the Labour Code because of trade union resistance, and the first experience with supporting the creation of social enterprises is far from positive. A symbolic cut in contributions for the self-employed will not help much and only further erodes a leaky contribution system. Only the measures in the tax area (an increase in the tax-free part of the tax base, the employee bonus, faster VAT refunds, simpler accounting and depreciation) perhaps show a hint of a systemic approach.


If we take into account the superficiality of markets in assessing differences between the countries of the Central and Eastern European region, the relative increase in the cost of Slovak production and exports as a result of the introduction of the euro, the low predictability of the business environment, weak law enforcement and limited labour market flexibility, Slovakia's prospects for a rapid economic recovery are not particularly rosy. If we add political uncertainty in the election year of 2010 and exhausted public finances threatening tax increases or unpopular cuts in government programmes, we get a likely picture of a country that will stand as one of many on the starting line of the post-crisis race for investors' favour.


We have no time to spare; soon even the last signs of expert debate on economic policy will be overshadowed by pre-election canvassing. The Minister of Finance should therefore stop joking and urgently start adopting measures to stabilise public finances. He should also dust off some of the ideas from the National Reform Programme or the Slovakia 21 Modernisation Programme and press his colleagues to implement policies in their ministries that lead to greater competitiveness of the country. The crisis has not yet fully manifested itself in Slovakia, but one day it will certainly come to an end. Then the cards will be dealt anew in the game for economic prosperity; we need to prepare for that moment already now.


Ján Marušinec


MESA10


The article was published on 6.4.2009 in the daily SME.

Translated from Slovak · 7 April 2009