The calm surface of evasive government statements on economic developments and public finances has recently been ruffled by the Ministry of Finance's newly published tax revenue forecasts, the Prime Minister's estimate of this year's deficit at above 6% of GDP, and the Finance Minister's subsequent musings to the Financial Times about raising taxes. Yet this is merely the logical outcome of the current government's fiscal policy steps, which are marked by helplessness in the face of economic decline.
This is not a matter of incompetence at the Ministry of Finance, but of the coalition parties' chronic political unwillingness to adopt unpopular but necessary measures on the expenditure side. To use a football analogy, the idea of raising taxes resembles an attempt to kick the ball into the stands with the message: we can't afford new boots, so we have to raise your ticket prices. It must be clear to everyone that a defender (of public finances) playing on a yellow card will have a hard time in the second half of the term of office. Let us, however, leave aside the state of public finances and look only at the possible tax increases hinted at by the Finance Minister.
Together with Romania, Slovakia, with the lowest share of taxes in GDP, is at the bottom of the EU league table. According to Eurostat data for 2007, the tax burden here amounts to 29.4% of GDP (this figure includes both taxes and social contributions). That is more than 10 percentage points below the Union average, which was 39.9% of GDP. So the minister is right when he says that taxes here are low compared with Europe. If, however, we dig a little deeper into the statistics, we get a somewhat different picture of this yawning gap in taxation. For example, our close neighbours in the V4 take on average only 35.3% of GDP in taxes. If we take all the post-communist EU states as our sample, their average tax burden is only 33.7% of GDP (the highest being Hungary with 39.7%). It is precisely these countries with which it makes sense to compare ourselves, since it is with them that we compete for inflows of investment from the West. And in this competition our lower taxes represent a competitive advantage.
But it is not enough to look only at the overall level of the tax burden; its structure also matters. In terms of structure, taxes can be divided into direct taxes, which burden the factors of production, namely labour and capital, and indirect taxes, which burden consumption and property. Europe has traditionally taxed the factors of production more heavily than consumption and property. Labour fares worst: in 2007 its taxation brought European countries' budgets on average 19.4% of GDP. Together with the taxation of capital, revenues from direct taxes make up as much as 65% of total tax revenues. The remaining 35% is shared, very unevenly, between consumption and property. Taxes burdened consumption to the tune of 11.1% of GDP, whereas property accounted for only 2.9% of GDP. This is due above all to the application of a uniform system and minimum rates of VAT and excise duties throughout the European Union.
EU countries also differ considerably from one another in the structure of the tax burden. On the one hand there are countries such as Sweden, Germany and Italy, where direct taxes make up more than 70% of total tax revenues. At the opposite end is Bulgaria, which collects only 44.7% of its tax revenues from direct taxes. It is also the only country in the Union where indirect taxes exceed direct taxes in terms of yield. In this respect Slovakia departs from the European average mainly through the low taxation of property. Revenues from property taxes here amount to 0.6% of GDP, whereas the Union average is 2.9% of GDP. Paradoxically, we also tax labour less (11.6% of GDP compared with an average of 19.4% of GDP). However, this is due not only to low rates, but above all to the relatively narrow tax base in the case of social contributions.
Commenting on his thoughts about raising taxes to the Slovak media, the Finance Minister stated that "the tax system we have is a fair-weather tax system. It is certainly not a foul-weather one. The question now is whether we can assume that the whole world will return after a year or two to the boom times we had over the last six years." How can a fair-weather and a foul-weather tax system be defined? It is above all a matter of the structure of taxes, not their overall level. In periods of economic turbulence, budget revenues from direct taxes behave much more cyclically, while indirect and property taxes are mostly a stabilising component of tax revenues. This is borne out by data from our Ministry of Finance's current tax revenue forecast. Whereas the yield of personal income tax has fallen by an average of 14% compared with the November estimate (average decline for 2009 to 2011), and the yield of corporate income tax by as much as 23%, the decline in VAT amounts to 4.6% and in excise duties to only 2.3%. For property taxes the ministry even expects their yield to rise by 20%.
With the 2004 reform, our tax system significantly shifted the weight of taxation precisely towards indirect taxes. Whereas in 2001 direct taxes made up 64.4% of total tax revenues, in 2007 it was just under 60%. From the above facts it can clearly be deduced that our tax system is good precisely for foul weather. But that is not all. It is also extremely well suited to fair weather, since a lower tax burden on the factors of production stimulates economic activity and attracts new investors to Slovakia. In today's globalised world, movements of capital – and, thanks to our EU membership, of labour as well – are ever easier. Investors and mobile professionals (e.g. scientists or athletes) will simply go and pay their taxes where they get better conditions. If we therefore preserve the current attractiveness of direct taxation, it will mean a faster restart of the economy for us after the crisis.
So back to the question: how does our government envisage changes in taxes? Again I shall turn to a quotation from the Finance Minister: "I wouldn't rule anything out. It's all about calculations; we'll see what it would bring, where and when, and what effect it would have where. We'll see how the global economic crisis subsides." Minister Počiatek has the rare gift of expressing the government's strategic intentions briefly, clearly and comprehensibly. Since on Thursday, on TA3 television, the minister ruled out any more substantial tax increases during this government's term (it is not popular), this is evidently, for the time being, merely a matter of preparing public opinion for possible unpopular measures after the 2010 election.
What changes might there be in the tax area? Judging by the proposals the Ministry of Finance has presented or discussed in the past, the government will seek to eliminate exemptions in income tax. This could most affect the 2% tax assignation and the tax support for the third pillar of the pension system. Also in play is an increase in social contributions, not through a nominal increase in the rate but by adjusting the maximum assessment base (unifying it across the various types of contributions and raising it overall). This would affect above all high-income employees. Lower-income groups, for their part, will not be pleased if the new government does not extend the increase in the non-taxable part of the tax base and the employee tax bonus. The minister also mentioned higher taxes on alcohol and gambling, but from the budget's point of view this would be mere small change. The only things missing from the collection are perhaps the tax increases for banks and monopolies announced by the Prime Minister, and the musings about progressive taxation of legal entities. All these interventions in the tax system have one thing in common – they are merely cosmetic and not systemic.
So what should the government do when there is no other way out and taxes have to be raised? First and foremost, it should keep direct taxes low so as not to undermine the country's competitiveness. It could reunify the VAT rate at 19% and reconsider the current level of, and the whole host of exemptions from, energy excise duties. It would also be advisable to curb legal tax avoidance in the social contribution system and, as far as possible, to reduce their nominal rate. With a wider circle of contributors and a broader base for calculating contributions, this should be achievable without budgetary impact. Last but not least, the government should significantly strengthen property taxes, which are the lowest in the entire EU in Slovakia. Real estate should be taxed on the basis of its market value, and motor vehicle tax should not apply exclusively to businesses. Such an approach would moreover be socially fair, since wealth would be taxed to a greater extent when it is used rather than when it is created.
But above all, the government should look at its own spending. How could it happen, for example, that while the Finance Minister talks about savings and tax increases, the government last week quietly approved more than SKK 2 billion for the construction of a new football stadium in Bratislava? The Polish Finance Minister, Jacek Rostowski, put it very aptly in the same Financial Times article in which our minister announced tax increases: "Raising taxes is the last resort. If we do it, it will be because there is no other alternative for ensuring the stability of public finances." That says it all. Paraphrasing Minister Počiatek, we can conclude that the current Slovak government is a fair-weather government, and certainly not a foul-weather one.
Ján Marušinec
MESA10
The article was published in the weekly .týždeň, issue 28/2009.