News › 2018
Blog and essay · 18 October 2018 · Slovakia

Do We Have Too Many or Too Few Vocational Schools?

Before the summer we wrote that the network of gymnáziá (academic secondary schools) cannot be judged solely by the number of schools and pupils. Answers to the question of an efficient network and the optimal size of gymnáziá need to be sought in the regions, while also taking demographic projections into account. Does the same apply to secondary vocational schools?

Not all SOŠ are alike
Traditionally, the public distinguished between gymnáziá, academies, industrial schools and apprentice schools. The full names of the last three almost always made clear what kind of education they provided: business or hotel academies, construction or transport industrial schools, and a whole spectrum of apprentice schools. Since 2008 these schools have been categorised as secondary vocational schools, SOŠ. This label covers a wide variety of study and apprenticeship programmes. Here we find, for example, a five-year bilingual programme at a business academy ending with the maturita (school-leaving) examination, but also two-year bricklayer training leading to an apprenticeship certificate.

Analysing the efficiency of the vocational school network is more complicated than in the case of the gymnázium network. Gymnáziá generally teach two or three study programmes – a general one, one oriented towards foreign languages or mathematics, or a bilingual one. Vocational schools, by contrast, often house a dozen programmes under one “roof”, with and without the maturita, lasting from one to eight years. In this article we take a closer look at the development of vocational schools since 2008 and at the numbers of their pupils and teachers.

SOŠ are disappearing faster than gymnáziá
According to the latest data, the school network includes 440 secondary vocational schools with over 140 thousand pupils. (1) Since there are fewer than 74 thousand gymnázium students in Slovakia, it can be said that of every three secondary school students, two study at a vocational school and one at a gymnázium.

The rapid decline in the number of births in the first fifteen years after 1989 was reflected, with a natural time lag, in the number of pupils at secondary schools. The demographic decline of the child population stopped in 2006, and since then there has been a slight increase. (2) Although in recent years this has contributed to relatively stable numbers of gymnázium students, the number of pupils at vocational schools continues to fall – by almost 65 thousand over ten years.

Whereas gymnáziá have lost approximately 5 thousand pupils each year since 2009, vocational schools have in some years lost twice as many. As a result, the average number of pupils per school also fell more rapidly, and last year it was almost the same for both types (an average of 313 pupils per gymnázium and 319 per SOŠ). Today vocational schools have on average 89 fewer pupils than ten years ago. The number of schools has also fallen. While fewer than twenty gymnáziá have closed over ten years, over sixty vocational schools have done so.

Do SOŠ differ by founder?
Like gymnáziá, vocational schools in Slovakia are founded by self-governing regions (VÚC), churches and private founders. The share of schools founded by self-governing regions is around 78%, church vocational schools account for approximately 18% and private ones for 4%. The proportions are similar for gymnáziá.

Vocational schools founded by self-governing regions have approximately twice as many pupils as church and private vocational schools, which is also reflected in the number of teachers. Church schools, however, have long shown a lower number of pupils per teacher.

At all vocational schools, the fall in pupil numbers was accompanied by a fall in the number of teachers, of whom there are over 3 thousand fewer than in 2008. This is a sharper decline than among gymnázium teachers, whose numbers fell by half as much over the same period. Consequently, the number of pupils per teacher at vocational schools has converged with that at gymnáziá, and for both types of school it now hovers around 14.

The answer lies in the range of programmes and graduates’ employability
In terms of funding, vocational schools are more expensive than gymnáziá. Whereas a gymnázium student costs us almost 1,900 euros a year, the cost of study and apprenticeship programmes at vocational schools ranges from over 2,100 euros to over 3,700 euros per pupil. (3) This is another reason why the question of rationalising the vocational school network needs to be looked at more closely. At the same time, however, account must be taken not only of the cost of education but also, for example, of the regional distribution of schools and the employability of graduates.

In 2018 the largest group of unemployed secondary school graduates registered with labour offices consisted of graduates of study programmes ending with the maturita. However, these were also the graduates the labour market was able to absorb most quickly. Graduates of apprenticeship programmes without the maturita were significantly fewer, but over the same period their registered unemployment was higher. The fewest unemployed graduates came from gymnáziá, since a large proportion of them continue their studies at universities. (4)

The differences in the registered unemployment rate between graduates of study and apprenticeship programmes are long-standing. (5) In the current year, graduates of apprenticeship programmes showed the highest risk of unemployment in agriculture, construction, food processing and clothing manufacture. Among study programmes, the highest risk of unemployment was among graduates in printing, commerce, services and transport. For them, however, this risk fell significantly thanks to the high absorption capacity of the labour market. (6)

At the same time, to better assess graduates’ employability we should not rely solely on data on their registered unemployment. And if we want a more efficient school network with promising programmes, we should not be guided only by data for entire groups of programmes, but should also take into account, for example, graduates’ career paths. Today we do not monitor these sufficiently.

Pointless and key questions
Today a large number of SOŠ offer both apprenticeship and study programmes at the same time. The most pressing question is therefore not whether we have too many or too few vocational schools. Rather, we should ask whether some study programmes are too expensive, too close to one another, and whether there is demand for them. This largely determines graduates’ current employability and also the efficiency with which public resources are spent.

For vocational schools, however, one more question is key – how many of the programmes offered today prepare pupils for professions and activities that will be replaced by machines and digital technologies in the foreseeable future? According to OECD data, Slovakia is one of the countries most vulnerable to automation, robotisation and digitalisation, which will lead to the disappearance or radical transformation of many professions. (7) We will not avoid this. But by addressing the content, structure and prospects of programmes in the existing school network, we can avoid paying twice for the education of graduates who will soon need to retrain.

Peter Dráľ
analyst, To dá rozum project

The blog is part of a project supported by the European Social Fund through the Effective Public Administration programme.

Sources:

(1) CVTI SR (2018). Časové rady – stredné odborné školy a konzervatóriá [Time series – secondary vocational schools and conservatories].
(2) Herich, J. and Kováč, M. (2018). Vývojové tendencie ukazovateľov materských, základných a stredných škôl. Trendová analýza 2000 – 2017 [Development trends in indicators for nursery, primary and secondary schools. Trend analysis 2000–2017]. Bratislava: CVTI SR.
(3) MŠVVŠ SR (2018). Normatívy na rok 2018 [Per-pupil funding standards for 2018].
(4) Herich, J. (2018). Evidovaná nezamestnanosť absolventov stredných škôl, sezóna 2017/2018 [Registered unemployment of secondary school graduates, 2017/2018 season]. Bratislava: CVTI SR. p. 36.
(5) Ibid., p. 16 (chart 9).
(6) Ibid., p. 37.
(7) OECD (2016). Automation and Independent Work in a Digital Economy. Policy Brief on the Future of Work. Paris: OECD Publishing, p. 2.

This article was published on the Denník N blog.

Translated from Slovak · Author: Peter Dráľ · 18 October 2018