News › 2019
Survey results · 16 April 2019 · Slovakia

Head teachers have extensive powers, but in managing their schools they come up against a lack of capacity and weak support

We presented our findings on school management at a press conference on 16 April 2019.

Press release in PDF

The current powers of head teachers in Slovakia are relatively extensive. This is repeatedly confirmed by the so-called school autonomy index in the OECD PISA surveys.

In addition to tests for pupils, these also include a school questionnaire completed by head teachers. In it, they also state who makes decisions on various aspects of school management, with the index calculated from the share of answers in which the head teacher, teachers or the school board are indicated. The last such survey in 2015 showed that Slovakia ranks 7th of all participating countries in terms of school autonomy. From the perspective of the PISA survey participants, therefore, decisions on various matters in Slovakia are taken at school level to a significantly greater extent than the OECD average or than in neighbouring Poland, Hungary or Austria.

Head teachers also reported relatively broad powers in the qualitative and quantitative surveys of To dá rozum (Learning Makes Sense). In the questionnaire survey, a large proportion of them stated that they decide on the admission of pupils to the school (90.2%), on drawing up the school rules (80.6%) and on the selection of teachers (79.3%). Together with the school's bodies and teachers, they also decide on staff remuneration and on what will be taught at the school. The head teacher's agenda also covers the school's finances and its operation, as well as communication with parents and the wider public. At the same time, head teachers are obliged to provide a large amount of data to the founding body and to various state authorities both within and outside the education sector.

Interviews with head teachers at all levels of education showed that they consider their powers sufficient. The head of the Evangelical Joint School in Prešov, Marián Damankoš, is convinced that "we already have so many powers in education that when we want to, we can get things moving. What is missing, however, is the motivation of some teachers and a larger volume of resources that a head teacher would have at their disposal to motivate them."

Respondents' answers also point to other obstacles to the successful management of schools. "The main problems appear to be head teachers' insufficient time and staff capacity, as well as their weak methodological support and inadequate continuing training in management matters," says Peter Dráľ, analyst of the To dá rozum project. Because of the many areas they are responsible for, head teachers are often left with no room for what matters most – improving the quality of the teaching process and managing human resources. "In other words, head teachers can make sure the timetable is drawn up, but they mostly no longer have the capacity to actively engage in methodological and professional guidance for teachers. In managing the team, they must and can handle personnel administration, but they lack the capacity and skills to improve internal communication, strengthen teamwork and involve school staff in running the school," warns Peter Dráľ.

One of the things that could help head teachers is the provision of training programmes to improve their management skills. According to the To dá rozum survey, however, the so-called functional training, which is compulsory for head teachers, helped only a fifth (20%) of them. Most (65.9%) see its benefit mainly in networking and exchanging experience. Although this is an important form of support, it does not directly develop management skills. "This was also one of the reasons why Profesia launched its academy for head teachers. Its main aim is to connect heads of primary and secondary schools with experts from companies, the non-profit sector and innovative schools in order to provide them with high-quality training in looking after the school's human resources. We believe that good people management and the resulting atmosphere in schools can help make working in education more attractive," says Anna Podlesná from the company Profesia.

According to the findings of To dá rozum, it is not appropriate to improve conditions in the area of school management by giving head teachers additional powers. On the contrary, it is necessary and desirable to relieve them of dealing with a multitude of "operational" matters so that they have more capacity for the strategic development of the school, managing people and improving the quality of the teaching process. This requires not only sufficient resources for administrative and specialist staff, but also access to meaningful support and advice so that they can further develop their skills and exchange examples of good practice.

________________________________________

TO DÁ ROZUM: is an initiative preparing a comprehensive change in education built on an analysis of problems in practice and on examples of good practice from Slovakia and abroad.

The project is supported by the European Social Fund through the Effective Public Administration programme.

Translated from Slovak · 16 April 2019