News › 2018
Blog and essay · 13 December 2018 · Slovakia

What Do We Learn and What Should We Be Learning at Secondary Schools?

What children learn is shaped by the demands of society. When designing the content of education, it is important to bear in mind that we are not preparing pupils for the world we live in now, but for the world that is to come.

The success of how the state curriculum is set up will therefore show not in testing, but only in the future, for example in how well prepared young people are for further study, working life and personal life. In a recent article on the To dá rozum (Learning Makes Sense) blog, my colleague Katarína Vančíková (1) looked at what employers expect of their employees. According to the employers involved in the survey, the most important competences include the ability to cooperate with others, motivation for further study and for work, and the ability to adapt to change. Do schools support the development of these competences? What priorities do today’s schools have in developing their pupils? How do secondary school students perceive the development of their competences?

The vision: from knowledge to competences
Over recent decades, the nature of education has been gradually changing in the global context. Education policies have gradually shifted from a system focused on knowledge towards the development of competences. In other words, countries are trying to find ways for schools to support not only the acquisition of isolated knowledge and skills, but also pupils’ ability to use them in everyday working and life situations. This transformation has been influenced by a number of factors: e.g. population ageing, growing migration, the marginalisation of some population groups, the likelihood of changing jobs during one’s working life, and the increasing pace of technological progress. In 2008 the Slovak education system, too, sought to move to a competence-based model of education. Essentially, the tendency at state level is to set up the education system so as to bridge the mismatch between the objectives and content of education and the demands of society, which are described, among others, in a World Economic Forum study (3) or in the Education and Training Monitor (4). However, the Educational Policy Institute (5) pointed out in a recent analysis that even though the state educational programmes for the individual levels of education describe the competences pupils should acquire, the content of individual subjects does not support this tendency.

The reality: from knowledge to… more knowledge?
In Slovakia we currently have a state educational programme for nursery, primary and secondary schools based on a competence model. (6) On the basis of the competences identified, the state educational programmes set out educational areas (language and communication, mathematics and logic, people and society, people and the world of work, people and values, art and culture, people and nature, health and movement). The educational areas include individual subjects, for which topics (content standard) and objectives for each topic (performance standard) are defined. The performance standards for individual secondary school subjects focus primarily on remembering and understanding (they specify everything the pupil should be able to define, explain, list, etc.). Occasionally there are also objectives at the level of applying knowledge (students are to give examples, solve simple tasks, etc.). A cross-cutting shortcoming of the educational programmes is the almost complete absence of requirements for the development of attitudes and values, even in subjects such as ethics or civic education. Such an approach significantly weakens the potential of education for democratic citizenship, responsibility and moral values. The absence of the application of knowledge and skills in various contexts is also a real obstacle to fulfilling the vision of education focused on developing competences.

According to secondary school heads, we focus mainly on subject knowledge
Schools draw up their own school programmes on the basis of the state educational programmes. In their own curricula, schools are not supposed to extend the content of education in individual subjects. They are, however, allowed to deepen knowledge, e.g. by using knowledge to solve more complex tasks or by analysing issues in different contexts. Within their school programmes, schools may freely adjust the content of individual subjects in terms of the sequence of topics, and look for links between curriculum areas so that pupils gradually perceive the connections between the topics they learn and can use knowledge from one subject in another. Schools therefore have the opportunity, to the extent permitted by the State Educational Programme, to adapt the content of education to their priorities. Schools can determine the importance of what they plan to focus on according to the educational preferences of their pupils, on the basis of communication with universities, according to the values they want to cultivate, but also on the basis of trends in scientific and technological progress and in education. The head of a secondary vocational school explains in the qualitative part of the To dá rozum research (7): “The content changed very often. And it changed also because the technological revolution kept bringing new knowledge. It is not a finite process. Just as science and technology enter production processes, schools must also adapt in order to prepare pupils for these technological changes.” The head teacher’s statement points to the benefit of drawing up school educational programmes: updating subject content in line with technological progress, with labour market expectations of secondary school graduates, or in the context of wider societal demands, but also with regard to pupils’ educational needs. Given the possibility of adjusting subject curricula in individual schools’ educational programmes, in the To dá rozum survey (2) we were interested in what priorities schools set when drawing up school documents. Secondary school heads answered this question in the questionnaire.

For more than half of the secondary school heads involved in the To dá rozum questionnaire survey (2), the priorities at their schools are developing knowledge of individual subjects, reading comprehension and financial literacy. By comparison, employers who took part in the To dá rozum survey (1) point to the importance of competences such as the ability to learn, teamwork and motivation to learn. From the schools’ perspective, the ability to learn is considered a priority by only about one fifth of the schools involved in the survey, while teamwork and motivation to learn and work are an important topic for just under a third of schools.

Communication between employers and schools is lacking
One reason for the differences between employers’ expectations and educational priorities may be that schools are not used to communicating with employers when setting up their educational programmes (by way of illustration, according to the To dá rozum survey (2), only 13% of secondary schools cooperate with employers to some extent in planning the content of education). Another cause may be the extent to which school managers follow educational trends when planning the content of education and are sensitive to how scientific and technological progress is affecting the nature of occupations. Clearly, in some sectors changes occur relatively quickly and school managers may not catch all of them. This is another reason why cooperation with employers can be beneficial. Firms work with the most up-to-date information, among other things on the visions and trends in their sector. Given that a school has a certain degree of freedom in designing the content of education, cooperation with employers could ensure that what pupils learn is up to date. Communication would make it possible to a greater extent to trim the content of education of topics and areas that are not essential. At the same time, it would create room for strengthening the skills needed for successful employment or study, both within and beyond the field of study.

Not only employability, but also educating citizens matters
Another problem is the insufficient support for those competences that lead to the education of citizens.

More than a third of secondary school heads in the To dá rozum survey (2) cite the development of ethical behaviour as one of their priorities. At the same time, however, it is still the case that subjects such as ethics or civic education are most often taught by non-specialists. (8) In the light of a recent survey by the Focus agency for the Youth Council of Slovakia (9) on the voting preferences of first-time voters, the insufficient support for areas related to responsible citizenship takes on a new context. This survey suggests that in civic education and in supporting active participation in civic life, young people’s involvement in various youth organisations plays a more important role than school. School also does not give pupils enough support in critically evaluating news on the internet, so they are more susceptible to media-active groups that often call democratic values into question. This result is also supported by the To dá rozum survey (2), in which only 18% of secondary school heads consider critical thinking an educational priority for their school, and just under 16% see the development of civic competences as an important topic. In other words, fewer than one in five secondary school heads involved in our To dá rozum survey (2) regard these topics as important.

Isolated knowledge vs applicability at work and in life
As is evident from the preceding findings, we can hardly say that extensive, isolated knowledge from various subjects is key to success in employment, nor is it a key aspect of personal or civic life. Of course, we are not downplaying the expertise needed to practise various professions or for further study. What matters, however, is to ask whether all pupils need to master isolated knowledge from every area and every subject, and whether school should not be more attentive to the world for which it is preparing them. We therefore need to consider whether extensive knowledge, which is easy to look up and readily available, should not be replaced in schools by the development of life skills that will support pupils’ potential to succeed in future study and in their working, personal and civic lives.

Petra Fridrichová
analyst, To dá rozum project

The article is an abridged version of the chapter Content of education from nursery school to university in the Analysis of Findings on the State of Education in Slovakia, available at: https://todarozum.sk/analyza/docs/342388001lb1a/

The blog is part of a project supported by the European Social Fund through the Effective Public Administration programme.

Sources:
(1) Vančíková, K. (2018). Čo očakáva pracovný trh od absolventov stredných odborných škôl? [What does the labour market expect of secondary vocational school graduates?]. Available at: https://dennikn.sk/blog/1151585/co-ocakava-pracovny-trh-od-absolventov-strednych-odbornych-skol/
(2) To dá rozum (unpublished report). Outputs of the representative survey of nursery, primary and secondary schools (including special schools), conducted as part of research into the problems of Slovak education in 2018.
(3) The Future of Jobs Employment, Skills and Workforce Strategy for the Fourth Industrial Revolution. Available at: http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_ Future_of_Jobs.pdf
(4) Education and Training Monitor. The Monitor is the European Commission’s flagship annual publication on education and training in the EU. Available at: http://ec.europa.eu/education/policy/strategic-framework/et-monitor_en
(5) Rehuš, M. (2018) Encyklopedizmus náš každodenný. Analýza kurikula v základných školách [Our daily encyclopaedism. An analysis of the primary school curriculum]. Available at: https://www.minedu.sk/data/att/13792.pdf
(6) ŠPU. (2015) Inovovaný štátny vzdelávací program [Revised State Educational Programme]. Available at: http://www.statpedu.sk/sk/svp/inovovany-statny-vzdelavaci-program/
(7) To dá rozum (2017). Outputs of a preliminary analysis of interviews with various stakeholders in education, conducted as part of qualitative research into the problems of Slovak education (unpublished material).
(8) Statistical Yearbook – summary tables. Available at: http://www.cvtisr.sk/cvti-sr-vedecka-kniznica/informacie-o-skolstve/statistiky/statisticka-rocenka-publikacia/statisticka-rocenka-suhrnne-tabulky.html?page_id=9603
(9) Youth Council of Slovakia. Mladí sa prikláňajú k extrémistom, ich voľbu ovplyvňuje internet. Tlačová správa [Young people lean towards extremists, their vote is influenced by the internet. Press release]. Available at: http://mladez.sk/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/TS_Mlad%C3%AD-sa-prikl%C3%A1%C5%88aj%C3%BA-k-extr%C3%A9mistom-ich-vo%C4%BEbu-ovplyv%C5%88uje-internet.pdf

About the survey
The questionnaire from which the data are drawn was developed on the basis of qualitative interviews conducted between May and September 2017 with various stakeholders in education (pupils, teachers, head teachers, teaching assistants, public administration representatives, etc.). Quantitative data were collected through questionnaires between May and June 2018. A total of 687 schools took part in the questionnaire survey in regional education (194 nursery schools; 35 special nursery schools; 214 primary schools; 97 special primary schools; 107 secondary schools; 40 special secondary schools), with a total of 5,469 respondents from these schools (3,657 teachers; 619 head teachers; 391 teaching assistants; 332 guidance counsellors; 275 vocational training instructors and 195 specialist staff). The survey used a representative sample of schools selected by quota random sampling with regard to region and founder. The overall response rate was as high as 52.28%. The questionnaire survey among secondary school pupils involved 2,827 secondary school students from all over Slovakia, who took part voluntarily in an online survey. In its scope and representativeness, it is a truly unique survey in the Slovak context.

This article was published on the Denník N blog.

Translated from Slovak · Author: Petra Fridrichová · 13 December 2018