On 3 October 2019, at a press conference, we presented the Analysis of Findings on the State of Education in Slovakia and began gradually publishing the final report and the qualitative data from the preparatory phase of the project. On 3–4 October 2019, a two-day national conference – a discussion with public policy stakeholders – was held at the Austria Trend Hotel in Bratislava (conference programme).
The full analysis is available in the Zenodo repository.
Press release: The problems in education are many and serious. The state has failed to address them for a long time
In 2016, the non-profit organisation MESA10 launched the To dá rozum initiative with the aim of defining the causes of the current unfavourable state of the education system in Slovakia and proposing changes to it.
Besides acquiring important knowledge and developing skills, education should enable the holistic development of children, pupils and students. It should help remove inequalities, meet needs and develop the potential of every learner to the greatest possible extent. Universities should, in addition, also contribute to the creation of new knowledge and the development of culture. At the same time, education should also prepare people for their future personal, civic and professional lives. According to the findings of the To dá rozum initiative, however, the reality is different.
Between 2017 and 2019, the initiative carried out an extensive qualitative and quantitative survey with more than 650 interviewees and 15 thousand questionnaire respondents from the field of education as well as from among employers. "In terms of the number of respondents reached and the comprehensiveness of the approach, this is a unique survey in Slovakia," explains Renáta Hall, director of the To dá rozum initiative. The survey is the basis for the Analysis of Findings on the State of Education in Slovakia, which is being presented publicly for the first time at today's conference. Its purpose is to describe the situation and identify the key problems of education, their causes, contexts and impacts. The findings of the analysis are serious, in many cases even alarming, from pre-school education to higher education.
One of the key problems is that education in Slovakia is not accessible to everyone at all levels. Today almost anyone can get into university, but access to early childhood education and care programmes is limited. The education system is unable to mitigate the risks of later failure early enough and thus does not create equal opportunities for all. Various costly measures are implemented within it, such as zero grades or courses for completing primary education, which are introduced as a result of the failure of prevention at previous levels of education. Yet the analysis shows that they are not effective.
Education today is unable to respond to the diversity of needs and interests of children, pupils and students in schools. On the contrary, some groups, such as children with disabilities or children from segregated Roma settlements, are systematically excluded from education. As a result of a lack of support that does not come at the right time, children's initial difficulties multiply further during their educational path. Many of them leave education without completing a level that would allow them to continue studying, or without attaining a qualification that would enable them to find a place on the labour market.
In primary schools, almost one pupil in five has recognised special educational needs. The increase in the number of these children may also be linked to the funding system, as the provision of a higher per-pupil normative allocation for a pupil with a disability or with a talent may, paradoxically, indirectly encourage over-diagnosis. At the same time, almost half of these pupils are educated separately in the special education system. Yet staff of both mainstream and special schools themselves would welcome greater cooperation between the two types of school. Another important finding is that many teachers in mainstream schools are not prepared to educate children with diverse needs, and supplementing their training in this area is practically unavailable to them.
Teachers are not sufficiently prepared either to master a wide range of teaching methods, or to recognise the needs of individual learners, or to reflect them in their teaching. Teachers' pay is not sufficient and their social recognition is not commensurate with the demands of their profession. The To dá rozum analysis also showed that the training of future teachers focuses mainly on developing theoretical knowledge – that is, what to teach – and not practical pedagogical skills – how to teach. Moreover, future teachers are mostly prepared for their profession using outdated methods. Nor does the system of professional development of current teachers sufficiently develop their pedagogical skills. An alarming finding of the survey is that almost three quarters of secondary school students said they had often, occasionally or at least once encountered a teacher humiliating pupils in front of their classmates (for example by using nicknames, ridiculing them, etc.). Almost 60% of university students had also encountered humiliation.
The content of education in Slovakia is not defined in such a way as to ensure, alongside the acquisition of important knowledge, the development of the necessary skills. Teaching in schools does not support active inquiry, nor the development of critical thinking, ethical behaviour, creativity, the ability to cooperate or civic engagement. According to teachers themselves, the dominant teaching methods are discussion of the topic and explanation of the subject matter. These, however, do not support the acquisition of various learning strategies usable throughout life, do not motivate pupils to explore and look for connections between topics, nor do they develop analytical and critical thinking. These are precisely the skills that employers also expect from graduates. According to teachers, the obstacles to using activating teaching methods are not only time and material factors, but also a lack of methodological support when introducing new methods into practice.
Universities in Slovakia are characterised by insularity. Students remain at one university throughout all levels of study, and academics from graduation to the end of their university careers. They thus miss out on diverse knowledge in scientific, artistic and teaching activities, as well as in university governance. Only some doctoral students are trained in basic research and teaching skills. University teachers are often not rewarded for high-quality teaching. Weak preparation for teaching and the lack of recognition for high-quality teaching contribute to the unfavourable image of teachers among university students. At private universities, students appear to be more at the centre of attention, which is reflected in their more positive perception of their studies and teachers than at public universities. Passive methods and forms of teaching dominate at universities. According to as many as a third of university students, teachers read texts to them in class. The emphasis is on specialist knowledge, which, however, a third of students consider outdated, and less on the skills needed for personal and working life. Plagiarism appears to be a widespread practice at universities, mainly due to ignorance of how to cite and the absence of sanctions.
The share of university students leaving to study at universities abroad has long been well above the average in OECD countries. The problem is that as many as 41% of them do not want to return and 18% do not know whether they will return to Slovakia. The main reason for leaving appears to be the greater prestige of universities abroad, based on the recommendations of students who already study in the given country or university. For more than three quarters of students abroad, the abolition of entrance interviews at most Slovak universities was also a signal of the declining quality of Slovak universities. According to the survey results, university students abroad are also better developed in the skills valued by employers. More than half of the human resources specialists in the survey expressed the view that graduates of universities abroad are better prepared, highlighting their better command of English, independence in carrying out tasks, and motivation and eagerness to learn and work.
Education in Slovakia is neither well governed at system level nor sufficiently and efficiently funded, from nursery schools all the way to universities. Head teachers mostly lack the necessary training, and many of them do not receive sufficient management support from their founding bodies, which for most schools are local and regional governments. Looking after school infrastructure, carrying out public procurement, and financial and personnel administration take many head teachers' capacity away from more important areas, such as the strategic development of the school, improving the quality of the teaching process and managing staff.
In the case of higher education, the problem is that the governance of public universities in particular is complicated and not all voices are heard in it. Only some university staff and students vote and are elected to academic senates. At the same time, there appear to be no effective mechanisms for systematically involving students in improving the quality of their own studies. Rectors and deans, as managers, do not have the power to take decisions; they can only propose them. The data obtained also suggest that several universities are internally fragmented, which reduces the potential for cooperation between their constituent parts in teaching, scientific and artistic activities, as well as for the efficient management of administrative and operational activities. Only in some of the scientific boards, which share responsibility for stimulating quality in science, the arts and teaching, are scientists with internationally above-average performance, or with above-average performance within Slovakia in locally specific social sciences and humanities, predominant.
The problem is that the state has no long-term vision for the development of education, and it neither systematically processes data nor analyses the impacts of the policies implemented. This contributes to frequent changes in legislation and in the method of funding. At the same time, the state does not provide sufficient support to the staff working in education. All these factors contribute to the continuous decline in the quality of education in Slovakia, which is evident from international comparisons and also from pupils' worsening results in national testing.
{UX3Ni1QW1ko}
________________________________________
TO DÁ ROZUM: is an initiative preparing a comprehensive change in education built on an analysis of problems in practice and on examples of good practice from Slovakia and abroad.
The project is supported by the European Social Fund through the Effective Public Administration programme.









